On the Authenticity of Tabuk Treaties about Jizya
https://doi.org/10.22311/2074-1529-2024-20-4-53-72
Abstract
The article completes the formal (hadithological) and substantive verification of the traditions about the tribute Jizya as the motive for the Tabuk expedition (in the ninth year of the Hijra), which was started in the fourth issue for 2023 and continued in the third issue for 2024. These traditions concerning the imposition of such tribute on Christians and Jews from the cities of Eilat, Azruh, Jarba and Maqna (to which the peoples of Azriat, Tabuk and Tayma are sometimes added) are subjected to critical analysis. The study is conducted in line with the reformist orientation towards the reconstruction of traditional political theology and overcoming the exclusivist-militantist interpretations of the Quran teaching and Prophet’s mission.
About the Author
T. K. Ibrahim
Institute of Oriental Studies of the Russian Academy of Sciences
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Tawfiq K. IBRAHIM, Dr. Sci. (Philos.), main research scientist, Center of Arab and Islamic Studies
12, Rozhdestvenka Str., Moscow, 107031
References
1. [Abu Dawd] (2007). Sunan Abī Dā w̄ d. Riyadh: Dā r al- Ma‘ā rif. 1198 p.
2. Abu ‘Ubayd (1989). Kitāb al-’Amwāl . Beirut-C airo: Dār ash-S hurūq . 807 p. Аl- Asqalani (1991). Taqrī b at- Tahdhī b. Aleppo: Dā r ar- Rashī d. 788 p.
3. Аl- Ayni (2001). ‘Umdat al-qā rī : sharh Sahī h al- Bukhā rī . Vol. 15. Beirut: Dā r al- Kutub al-‘ilmiyya. 437 p.
4. Аl- Baladhuri (1987). Futūh al-buldā n. Beirut: Mu’assasat al- Ma‘ār if. 768 p.
5. Аl- Bayhaqi (1985). Dalā’ il an-nubūw wa. Vol. 5. Beirut: Dār al- Kutub al‘ilmiyya. 418 p.
6. Bolshakov O. G. (1989–1993). Istoriya Khalifata [History of the Caliphate]. Vol. 1. Moscow: Nauka Publ. 312 p.
7. [al- Bukhari] (2002). Sahīh al-B ukhār ī . Damascus-B eirut: Dār Ibn-K athīr . 1944 p.
8. Chomaev Z. A. (2021). Musul‘manskaya diplomatiya v ranneislamskuyu epohu: zarozhdenie i osobennosti funktsionirovaniia (622–661 gg.) [Muslim Diplomacy in the Early Islamic Era: Origin and Features of Functioning (622–661); PhD thesis]. Moscow: Institute Vostokovedeniya RAN Publ. 247 p.
9. Ibn Asakir (1995). Tā rī kh madī nat Dimashq. Vol. 2, 21. Beirut: Dā r al- Fikr. 423, 495 p.
10. Ibn Hanbal (1998–1999). Musnad al-imā m Ahmad ibn Hanbal. Vol. 24, 27. Beirut: Mu’assasat ar- Risā la. 419, 386 p.
11. [Ibn Hisham] (n. d.). As- Sīr a an-nabawī yya li- Ibn- Hishām . Vol. 1–2. Beirut: Mu’assasat ‘Ulū m al- Qur’ā n; Jiddah: Dā r al- Qibla. 834, 766 p.
12. Ibn al-J awzi (1986). Kitā b ad- Du‘afā ’ wa-l-matrū kī n. Vol. 2. Beirut: Dā r al- Kutub al-‘ilmiyya. 250 p.
13. Ibn Kathir (1997). Al-B idāy a wa-n-nihāy a. Vol. 7. Cairo: Dār Hajar. 690 p. Ibn Kathir (1999). Tafsīr al- Qur’ā n al-‘azīm . Vol. 4. Riyadh: Dār Tī ba. 617 p.
14. [Ibn Khaldunn] (2000). Tā rī kh Ibn Khaldū n. Vol. 2. Beirut: Dā r al- Fikr. 656 p.
15. Ibn Sad (2001). Kitā b at- Tabaqā t al-kabī r. Vol. 1–2. Cairo: Maktabat al- Khā njī . 445, 342 p.
16. Ibn Zanjawayh (1986). Kitā b al-A mwā l. Vol. 1–3 (end-to-end numbering). Riyadh: Markaz al-malik Faysal. 1430 p.
17. Ibrahim T. K. (2021). Ob istorichnosti Nadzhranskogo dogovora o dzhizje: datirovka, al’ternativnye versii [On Historicity of the Najran Treatise on Jizya: Dating and Alternative Versions]. Islam v sovremennom mire. 2021. Vol. 17. Iss. 2. Pp. 27–48.
18. Ibrahim T. K. (2023). O dzhizje kak motive Tabukskogo pohoda: kriticheskij analiz predanij ob ajatah 9: 28–29 [On Jizya as a Motive for the Tabuk Expedition: on the Ayat 9: 28–29]. Islam v sovremennom mire. 2023. Vol. 19. Iss. 4. Pp. 51–66.
19. Ibrahim T. K. (2024). Kriticheskij analiz predanij o dzhizje s hristian
20. Dumat-al’-Dzhandalya [Critical Analysis of Traditions about Jizya from the Christians of Dumat al-J andal]. Islam v sovremennom mire. 2024. Vol. 20. Iss. 3. Pp. 71–92.
21. Аl-M asudi (1938). At- Tanbī h wa-l-ishrā f. Cairo: Maktabat ash-S harq al-islā miyya. 423 p.
22. [Muslim] (2000). Sahī h Muslim. Riyadh: Dā r as- Salā m. 1488 p.
23. [an- Nasai] (2015). Sunan an- Nasā ’ī . Riyadh: Dā r al- Hadā ra. 992 p.
24. Qudama ibn Jafar (1981). Al- Kharā j wa-sinā ’at al-kitā ba. Baghdad: Dā r ar- Rashī d. 623 p.
25. [Аt- Tabari] (1968–1969). Tā rī kh at- Tabarī (Tār īk h ar-rusul wa-l-mulūk ). Vol. 2, 3. Cairo: Dā r al- Ma‘ā rif. 664, 632 p.
26. Аt- Tahawi (2010). Sharh Mushkil al-ā thā r. Vol. 7. Damascus: Dā r ar- Risā la al-‘ā lamiyya. 474 p.
27. [Аt- Tirmidhi] (2005). Sunan at- Tirmidhī . Beirut: Dā r al- Kitā b al-‘arabī . 1231 p.
28. Аl-U qayli (2000). Kitā b ad- Du‘afā ’. Vol. 1–4 (end-to-end numbering). Riyadh: Dā r as- Sumay‘ī . 1568 p.
29. Аl- Waqidi (1966). Kitā b al- Maghā zī . Vol. 1–3 (end-to-end numbering). Beirut: ‘Ā lam al-kutub. 1321 p.
30. Yaqut al-H amawi (1977). Mu‘jam al-buldā n. Vol. 2. Beirut: Dā r Sā dir. 549 p.
Review
For citations:
Ibrahim T.K. On the Authenticity of Tabuk Treaties about Jizya. Islam in the modern world. 2024;20(4):53-72. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.22311/2074-1529-2024-20-4-53-72
Views:
91
Email this article 