The Phenomenon of Renewal in the Islamic Historical Tradition
https://doi.org/10.22311/2074-1529-2022-18-3-43-58
Abstract
This article is devoted to the phenomenon of renewal (tajdid) in historical Islam. This topic is particularly relevant in the context of understanding the origins of Islamic modernism and neo-modernism, namely their embeddedness in the religious tradition. The fi rst paragraph traces the origins and content of the idea of renewal in historical tradition. Particular attention is paid to the connection between renewal and the spiritual and ethical revival of society (islah). Variable and constant characteristics in the development of the historical understanding of renewal are demonstrated. The second paragraph analyzes an issue fundamental to the topic in question as the distinction between innovation (bid‘a) and renewal. It is shown that despite the rather conservative rhetoric of historical renewers, tajdid has a creative nature, but at the same time retains the difference from an arbitrary innovation. The third paragraph reveals the mentioned creative dimension of tajdid: its connection with the practice of independent reasoning (ijtihad) and overcoming imitative thinking (taqlid). In conclusion, the author notes the peculiarities of the modern interpretation of the tajdid: the rejection of a literal understanding of the concept of “age” in the hadith about renewal and the assumption of the possibility of a collective renewer.
About the Author
D. V. Mukhetdinov
Moscow Islamic Institute; Saint Petersburg State University
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Damir V. MUKHETDINOV, Dr. Sci. (Theol.), rector; Professor of the Faculty of Asian and African Studies
12, Kirova Lane, 109382, Moscow
11, Universitetskaya Emb., Saint Petersburg, 199034
References
1. Al-A fghani J. (2021). Otvet materialistam [Refutation of the Materialists]. Moscow: Medina. 64 p.
2. Al-G hazali A. H. (1980). Voskreshenie nauk o vere. Izbrannye glavy [The Revival of the Religious Sciences. Selected Chapters]. Moscow: Nauka. 376 p.
3. Al-Ghazali A. H. (2011). Ihja’ ‘ulum ad din (Vozrozhdenie religioznyh nauk) [The Revival of the Religious Sciences]. Vol I–III. Makhachkala: Nurul Irshad. 424+460+288 p.
4. Аl-Jabri M. (2017). Fikkhovyj razum: legitimaciya legitimatora [The Fiqhic Reason: Legitimising the Legitimiser]. Islamskay misl’: traditsiya i sovremennost’. Religiozno-filosofskiy ezhegodnik. Moscow: Medina. Vol. 2. Pp. 273–301.
5. Al-Qursawí A. N. (2005). Nastavlenie lyudej na put’ istiny (Al-Irshad li-l‘ibad) [Guidance to the People to the Path of Truth (Irshād li-l-‘ibād)]. Kazan: Tatarskoe knizhnoe izdatel’stvo. 304 p.
6. Boroday S. Yu., Mukhetdinov D. V. (2021). Islamskaya mysl’: priglashenie k tematicheskomu prochteniyu [Islamic Thougth: an Invitation to the Thematic Reading]. Islamskay misl’: traditsiya i sovremennost’. Religiozno- fi losofskiy ezhegodnik. Moscow: Medina. Vol. 5. Pp. 549–644.
7. Fakhretdin R. (2022). Religioznye i obshchestvennye voprosy [Religious and Social Issues]. Moscow: Medina. (In press)
8. Hallaq W. (2001). Authority, Continuity, and Change in Islamic Law. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 284 p.
9. Hernandez R. (2012). Framing the Jurist: the Legal Persona of Jalal al-Din al-Suyuti. Ph D. Washington, Georgetown University. vii + 282 p.
10. Ibn Khaldun (2008). Vvedenie (Al-M uqaddima) [Al-M uqaddima]. Istoriko-filosofskij ezhegodnik-2007. Moscow: 2008. Pp. 187–217.
11. Kamali M. H. (2020). Tajdid, islah i civilizacionnoe obnovlenie v islame [Tajdid, Islah and Civilisational Renewal in Islam]. Ostrog: Mezhdunarodnyi Institut Islamskoi Mysli. 58 p.
12. Landau-T asseron E. (1989). The “Cyclical Reform”: A Study of Mujaddid Tradition. Studia Islamica no. 70. Pp. 79–117.
13. Marjani Sh. (1883). Muqaddima: kitab vafi yat al-aslaf va takhiyat al-akhlaf [Details on Predecessors and Greeting to Descendants] Kazan: Tipografi ya G. M. Vyacheslava. 411 p.
14. Siebeking B. R. (2019) An Innovator, by Any Other Name: The Mujaddid and the Rhetoric of Islamic Renewal. Simkins R. A., Smith Z. B. (eds.) Supplement Series for the Journal of Religion & Society. Vol. 18. Pp. 45–62.
15. Voll J. (1983). Renewal and Reform in Islamic History: Tajdīd and Iṣlāh. Esposito J. (ed.) Voices of Resurgent Islam. New York; Oxford: Oxford University Press. Pp. 32–47.
16. Al-Zirikli H. (2002). Al-ʼa‘lam [Eminent Personalities]. Bejrut: Dar al-‘ilm li-l-malain, 2002.
17. Al- Sa‘idi ‘A. (1996). Al-mujaddidun fi -l-islam min al-qarn al-avval ila-rrabi‘ ‘ashar [Islamic Renewal Thinkers from the First to the 14th Century of the Hij ra]. Cairo: Maktabat al-adab.
18. Al-Huli A. (2001). Al-mujaddidun fi -l-islam. [Islamic Renewal Thinkers]. Cairo: Maktabat al-usra, 2001.
Review
For citations:
Mukhetdinov D.V. The Phenomenon of Renewal in the Islamic Historical Tradition. Islam in the modern world. 2022;18(3):43-58. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.22311/2074-1529-2022-18-3-43-58
Views:
478
Email this article 